Skip to Content

### Integrating Race in College Essays: Navigating Affirmative Action Challenges

CHICAGO (AP) — Hillary Amofa, an 18-year-old senior at Lincoln Park High School in Chicago, initially crafted her college essay around the expected narrative of her immigrant background from Ghana and upbringing in a modest Chicago apartment, emphasizing hardship and struggle. However, she eventually scrapped this version, realizing it failed to truly reflect her identity.

Following the Supreme Court’s decision impacting affirmative action in higher education, the college essay emerged as a pivotal space where considerations of race could influence admissions outcomes. This shift placed added pressure on students of color like Amofa to navigate the complexities of framing their experiences within the application process.

Amofa’s contemplation on addressing her racial heritage in her essay was met with uncertainty post the affirmative action ruling. She grappled with the dilemma of authentically sharing her background without being pigeonholed by it, a sentiment echoed by many peers facing similar challenges.

In the midst of exploring essay topics, Amofa encountered a prevalent theme among sample essays in her English class—centering on trauma or adversity to underscore personal growth. This trend prompted introspection on whether her own life experiences resonated sufficiently with the anticipated narrative of overcoming profound struggles to warrant attention from admissions committees.

Darrian Merritt, a senior from Cleveland, also felt compelled to align his essay with potential expectations of sharing a tragic or emotionally charged story to appeal to prestigious universities. However, he ultimately pivoted towards a narrative celebrating self-acceptance and personal growth at a summer camp, showcasing resilience and authenticity in his storytelling.

Max Decker, hailing from Portland, Oregon, recalibrated his essay focus post the Supreme Court ruling, shifting from a childhood anecdote about video games to a poignant reflection on his involvement with Word is Bond—a leadership group empowering young Black men. His essay underscored the significance of community and self-discovery, highlighting the transformative impact of embracing his identity.

Imani Laird from Newton South High School in Boston suburbs, emphasized the necessity of explicitly articulating the ways in which race shaped her experiences in the aftermath of the Supreme Court ruling. Her essay delved into familial history marred by racial discrimination, fueling her drive for academic excellence and a future in public policy.

As students grapple with the evolving landscape of college admissions post the affirmative action ruling, concerns loom over the potential ramifications on campus diversity and inclusivity. Amofa, contemplating her choices between universities with varying demographic compositions, harbors apprehensions about isolation and representation in predominantly white academic settings.

Amidst these challenges, students like Amofa strive to craft essays that authentically capture their journeys of self-discovery and empowerment. Her final essay celebrates embracing her natural hair as a symbol of self-acceptance and defiance against societal beauty standards, embodying a narrative of resilience and cultural pride.

The Associated Press’ education coverage receives financial support from multiple private foundations. AP is solely responsible for all content.