Skip to Content

### How CPS Favors Families with Abundant Resources in Principal Discretion Process

Across Chicago, some eighth graders are still awaiting notification regarding their acceptance into a selective enrollment high school within the Chicago Public Schools system. These students are eager for the opportunity to secure a coveted spot at a specific school.

Statistics indicate that only 16.5% of high school students in Chicago are granted admission to one of the 11 selective enrollment high schools, renowned as the city’s top educational institutions. Prospective students are required to exhibit outstanding academic performance through exceptional grade point averages and standardized test scores.

In 2021, there were fewer than 5,000 available seats in Chicago’s selective enrollment high schools. Students who are not accepted into their desired school have the option to seek special consideration through the principal discretion process at one of these schools. This process typically involves submitting a personal statement, letters of recommendation, and evidence of academic achievements.

However, the principal discretion process has been criticized for its shortcomings. Reports have highlighted disparities in the selection criteria, with a tendency for students from affluent neighborhoods to have an advantage due to their familiarity and resources to navigate the process effectively. Principals have the autonomy to choose students based on subjective criteria, leading to potential biases and inconsistencies across schools.

One poignant example is Lucia’s story, an immigrant from Peru, and her son Santiago, who had set his sights on attending Lane Tech since sixth grade. Despite Santiago’s impressive 4.0 GPA, their experience with the principal discretion process left them disillusioned. The lack of transparency and support in the application process added to their frustration and disappointment.

The challenges faced by families like Lucia’s underscore the need for a more inclusive and transparent school choice system. The existing barriers, as highlighted by researchers like Lauren Sartain, reveal the importance of providing adequate support and guidance to families navigating the complex process of selecting schools.

In Lucia’s case, the language barrier and lack of clear instructions further complicated their application journey. The absence of essential information in languages other than English, especially for a significant portion of Spanish-speaking families, raises questions about equity and accessibility in the system.

The emotional toll of the application process on Lucia, culminating in a missed deadline due to hidden requirements, reflects the systemic issues that deter many families from fully engaging in the school selection process. The burden placed on families, particularly those from marginalized backgrounds, to prove their worthiness for quality education is a systemic flaw that needs addressing.

As Chicago’s Board of Education devises a new strategic plan, it is imperative that the voices and experiences of families like Lucia’s are central to the decision-making process. Acknowledging the challenges faced by families who are often overlooked in the school choice process is crucial for fostering a more equitable and inclusive educational environment.

Shannon Paige Clark, a postdoctoral scholar at Northwestern University, specializes in researching educational policies and family engagement in schools.